Add as bookmark

Sound Therapies: Universal Panacea or Placebo?

by Pauline Allen(more info)

listed in sound and music, originally published in issue 59 - December 2000

The power of sound and music has been recognized since the earliest civilizations and incorporated in many aspects of cultural life, including religions, magic and healing.

A number of different sound therapies are now available, associated with claims that they can offer significant improvements for those with a range of physical, emotional and educational difficulties and/or promote general well-being and re-energise the mind-body system.

In recent years, there have been various initiatives to use both sound and music to help people with a wide range of difficulties. In some cases, sound therapy may be used to help with poor functioning attributable to physical, emotional, behavioural or learning difficulties.

In the medical world, sounds and music are increasingly used to reduce or eliminate pain during major surgery and dentistry and for the relief of pains in the joints. Music is also used to stimulate the overall mind-body system, for personal growth or perhaps to stimulate intellectual development and performance, in subjects like mathematics, or to improve behaviour and social interactions.

 

Matthew raises his hand to conduct the music
Matthew raises his hand to conduct the music

 

Sound Therapy or Music Therapy?

In this article, we are not concerned with the making of music for therapeutic purposes. We have therefore excluded voice work (singing, chanting, toning) and what is generally called 'music therapy', where people are encouraged to participate in the making of music to help with physical, emotional or behavioural difficulties. We are also excluding the use of music for relaxation and pain relief ('vibrational medicine', TENS, bio-acoustics, cymatics).

We have focused on approaches to 'sound therapy' that are designed specifically to correct distortions or imbalances in auditory processing. These may affect not just the hearing function but also the vestibular system, and thus many aspects of the mind-body system. Our initial interest was in helping children and adults with learning and sensory difficulties but some of the sound therapies are also powerful tools for helping with depression and re-energizing people after perhaps years of functioning below par. As a by-product, auditory change may be accompanied by other changes, linked to emotional and/or physical wellbeing. As Dr Bérard, creator of Auditory Integration Training (AIT), concluded, "everything happens as if human behaviour were largely conditioned by the manner in which one hears". He found so much evidence for this that he called his book Audition Égale Comportment (in American English: Hearing Equals Behavior).

Presenting Difficulties

Table 1 indicates the main difficulties for which each therapy is indicated but in Table 2 there is a more comprehensive list of the kinds of auditory processing difficulties and the presenting symptoms for which these therapies have been found useful. The range is wide and reflects the essential role of sound and hearing in our interactions with the world.

Table 1: Comparison of Sound Therapies
Type of Sound The Tomatis Method Auditory Integration

Johansen Sound Therapy

SAMONAS Sound Therapy The Listening Program
        Spectral Activated Music of Optimal Natural Structure)  
Location Clinic-based Clinic-based Home-based Home-based Home-based
Originator Dr Alfred TomatisMD and ENT specialist Dr Guy Bérard MD, surgeon, ENT specialist Dr Kjeld Johansen Educationalist specializing in the remediation of dyslexia Dr Ingo Steinbach Physicist, sound engineer and musician Alexander Doman, Joshua Leeds, Dr Ron Minson MD (psychology, psychoacoustics, and neuro-development)
Country of origin France France Denmark Germany USA
Indicated for: (see also Table 2 and text) Auditory processing disorders, including learning difficulties. Also offered for foreign language learning; and re-training singers with hearing difficulties Auditory processing disorders and distortions especially hyperacute hearing. Learning and behavioural difficulties, dyslexia, autism, depression. Speech, language and communication difficulties Dyslexia attributable to phonological difficulties; stroke patients with aphasia and alexia Difficulties associated with poor neurological functions and inter-hemispheric communication Listening and auditory processing problems, sound sensitivities, learning and attention deficits; also offered for improving communication skills, musical abilities and learning potential
Duration 2 hours a day for 3 weeks (30 hours) followed by 3-6 week gaps for consilidation before further intensives essions Total: 60-75 hours

2 x 30 minutes a day (minimum 4 hours apart) for 10 days

Total: 10 hours

10-15 minutes a day for 6-12 months 30-60 minutes a day for 12-18 months Normally 2 x 15 minutes per day in 8-week cycles; other possible schedules for special cases
Follow-on sessions Possibly several intensive sessions (16-30 hours) per year Normally one programme is enough. In severe cases, repeat possibly after 6 months As appropriate As appropriate

Originators claim it can be safely used as often or for as long as desired

Monitoring Throughout sessions Throughout sessions At 6 weeks and then 12-week intervals At 6 weeks and then 12-week intervals At end of each 8-week cycle
Main Activity Active listening; recording and listening to own voice Active listening only Active listening Active listening Active listening
Other activities while listening May read, write, draw, play games, converse, etc. No eating, drinking, reading, writing, drawing, talking etc. May read May read May read
Sound source CD or tape player feeding Electronic Ear to modulate/filter sound during listening CD or tape player feeding Audiokinetron to modulate/filter sound during listening Tapes specially pre-recorded or customized for clients Standard range of CDs specially pre-recorded using Envelope Curve Modulator Standard range of 8 specially pre-recorded CDs
Sounds used Music, especially Mozart, Gregorian Chant; own voice; mothers' voice Music with wide frequency range, orchestral richness and well-defined rhythm Music or natural soundds Classical chamber music or sounds of nature (birdsd, wind, water)

Classical music and nature sounds

 

Equipment for receiving sound Special headphones with air and bone conduction facility High quality headphones Good quality tape player; high quality headphones Good quality CD player; high quality headphones High quality headphones

Table 2: Is Sound Therapy Appropriate?

Difficulties that may be partly attributable to auditory processing difficulties

Auditory and Phonological Difficulties

Hypersensitive or painful hearing
Poor sound recognition
Poor language processing
Lack of speech
Stammering
Tinnitus
Central Auditory Processing Disorder (CAPD)
Dyslexia (reading, writing and spelling difficulties)
Poor marshalling of ideas
General Learning Difficulties
Poor memory, poor organization, poor concentration
Attention Deficit Disorder (ADD)
Hyperactivity, ADHD, challenging behaviour
Motor Problems
Dyspraxia, clumsiness, balance and co-ordination problems
Sensory integration problems and developmental delay
Other Difficulties
Autism and Asperger's Syndrome
Depression, Seasonal Affective Disorder

Assessment

In all our cases, assessment will follow a similar pattern: completion of a history questionnaire, detailed interview, standard tests (pure tone audiogram, laterality tests, selectivity tests), and exploration of options available. The most important assessment tool is the audiogram, which reveals whether the hearing profile and the associated behaviours are likely to be improved by sound therapy.

Clients may have previously had hearing tests in their quest to find reasons for their difficulties. In many cases the hearing threshold response departs considerably from the theoretical norm and they have been told that their hearing is 'within normal limits'. Generally this phrase indicates that, although there may be some hearing loss, the hearing threshold is above 25 or 30dBHL and there is not considered a need for a hearing aid or other medical intervention. This does not mean that auditory processing is unaffected, and it can be a false comfort to those seeking reasons for many educational, behavioural or emotional problems.

Sound therapists, however, are looking for specific aspects of the hearing profile: imbalance between left and right ears, extra acute hearing in one or both ears, poor hearing in one or both ears at specific frequencies, unusual peaks and troughs at certain frequencies and various other indicators apparent from the way they respond.

For instance, when the threshold is more sensitive than normal (hyperacute) it may have been discounted as a potential problem, yet this hyperacute response will often explain the covering of ears in noisy situations, difficulty in coping with loud domestic and street sounds, noisy environments such as classrooms or social gatherings (cocktail party deafness) and a reluctance to travel on the underground rail network. If such sound cannot be physically excluded then it may be 'tuned out'. Many with learning difficulties and autistic children without speech may have extra sensitive hearing in one or both ears, which causes them to filter out sounds to avoid discomfort or even pain.

There may have been ear infections that have affected the middle ear. The significance on the interpretation, processing or even the initial development of speech, of an auditory response with numerous variations in threshold, may also have been discounted, but experience shows that learning ability and emotional responses can be dramatically affected by the distortions generated within these 'normal limits'.

Which Sound Therapy?

Table 1 is a summary of the characteristics of five of the sound therapies offered in the UK. They come from different parts of the world and have been devised by professionals from various disciplines (doctors and ENT specialists, educationalists to physicists and sound engineers). The two clinic-based therapies have been developed by French ENT specialists: the first by Dr Alfred Tomatis, the second by Dr Guy Bérard who in fact consulted Dr Tomatis for his own tinnitus and encroaching deafness and then went on to develop his own protocols. The other three systems are home-based, using modified, pre-recorded audiotapes or CDs.

In all these sound therapies, the client is asked to listen through headphones to certain kinds of music or other sounds which are specially treated (modulated and/or filtered) to help correct the distortions in auditory processing which are affecting performance. It is essential that the recordings and playback equipment, including headphones, are of very good quality. In particular, the client needs to experience the high frequencies without distortion.

With both Bérard's AIT and the Tomatis Method the equipment used enables appropriate filtering to be introduced as well as modulating the music source, thus encouraging listening and attention to the whole frequency range, leading to a re-educated auditory system. With the Johansen system the tapes may be optionally customized.

Because the right ear provides the shortest route to the language centres in the left hemisphere, volume may be reduced in the left ear to encourage right ear dominance and thus improve speech perception and processing.

We generally favour AIT as, being a clinic-based approach, it is easier to customize, monitor and ensure that the correct protocols are being observed. We ask clients or parents to keep a daily diary of reactions, and by meeting twice daily it is easier to keep track of what is happening. Occasionally there may be temporary mood changes or increased tiredness. Children may have unexpected temper tantrums, generally short lived, but a sign that progress is being made. At such times, it is helpful to be at hand to reassure parents that all is well.

AIT is also more cost-effective for the client, being completed in just ten days. For clients who cannot easily get to the clinic for the ten days, because of distance or cost of travel/accommodation, then the home-based approach is a good alternative.

Although some of the home-based programmes are widely available, their use should still be carefully monitored by a professional sound therapist, since they are all potentially powerful interventions designed for therapeutic listening through headphones, and should not be considered as simply for casual relaxation and entertainment.

Outcomes: Universal Panacea or Mere Placebo?

Certainly sound therapies are not a universal panacea for all the conditions listed in Table 2 and specifically not recommended for schizophrenic individuals. However, if there are signs of auditory processing difficulties, we expect to find some improvements in the key areas causing concern; some may be immediate, within days; some may occur in the weeks or months following the intervention. Improvement depends upon the degree that the auditory system is contributory to the difficulty.

Many clients start to overcome learning and behavioural difficulties. The principal indications of improved auditory processing (including improved auditory discrimination and better phoneme segmentation skills) are not only better listening skills but also improved speaking, reading, spelling and memory skills. After being relieved of the frustration of not being able to process language satisfactorily, the behavioural and emotional problems start to disappear; e.g. the Attention Deficit Disorder (ADD) child discovers how to focus attention. For the non-verbal client with an autistic spectrum disorder, eye contact may improve or a gradual or even rapid speech development.

Those with depression change their outlook on life and feel more comfortable with their lives. The previously suicidal wonder what the problem was. The nightmare of tinnitus may in some cases reduce or even disappear. As mentioned above, some find as a by-product that the sound therapy has unexpectedly helped with other difficulties. With AIT we frequently note improvements in self-confidence, assertiveness, maturity and relationships with others. Improvements in sleeping and eating patterns are common. Clients have also reported positive effects in reducing or eliminating bulimia, anorexia, thyroid difficulties, psoriasis, eczema, asthma, horse allergies, addictions and obsessive-compulsive disorders.

Some commentators may wonder how much is attributable simply to spending time sitting quietly listening to music without distraction. Meditation, for example, with or without music, is reported to bring major physiological and emotional benefits. The objective test is whether the auditory profile has changed and whether associated improvements start occurring. It is our repeated experience that they do.

What's going on? It seems we don't know the answer to that yet. On AIT for instance, The Society of Auditory Integration Techniques (SAIT) has published a list of theories about why it is effective. They postulate changes in the middle ear, inner ear, and/or the brain, and include theories of conditioning, the effects on the vestibular system or biochemical changes.

What about independent research assessments rather than clinical reports? Unfortunately, like many areas in the complementary field, the few studies that have been done do not initially appear very encouraging for the outsider wondering whether this or that therapy will be helpful. One difficulty is the range of conditions for which these therapies are being used. Every client is different and has a different combination of experiences and presenting conditions. In severe cases, clients or parents may be desperate and have tried, or are trying, several other remedies at the same time, so it is difficult to disentangle what caused what benefit. It is difficult therefore to assemble an acceptably large test and control population with matching conditions. Another difficulty is that research tests are not necessarily carried out by fully trained practitioners and may not have followed the prescribed protocols or used the specified equipment. SAIT recently published an interesting commentary about a number of published research reports.

However, most practitioners keep their own records of case studies and are happy to put new clients in touch with clients with similar experiences. On this point, we suggest one of the most powerful recommendations for AIT is Dr Bérard's book, where he gives the results from clients coming to his own ENT practice. Of some 8,000 ENT clients, he identified 2,300 whom he felt would benefit from AIT. The outcomes are set out in Table 3.

Table 3: AIT: Outcomes from Dr Bérard's own Clinic

Source: Hearing Equals Behavior

Number of ENT clients 8,000
Number assessed as likely to benefit from AIT 2,300

Presenting with dyslexia

Very positive results

Noticeable partial improvement

No change

1,850

76%

24%

0%

Presenting with depression and suicidal tendencies

Cured after first treatment

233

93%

Presenting with autism

Significant behaviour modification, lost fear of noise

Complete cure

48

47

1

Dr Bérard's figures speak for themselves. Our own practice, using AIT, has also produced many heart-warming stories to tell about the transformation in people's lives initiated by sound therapy. One depressed dyslexic child said after AIT, "I have been given a new life. I feel I have gone through a tunnel and come out happy and clever", and the parent of a young boy with autistic tendencies and minimal speech commented, "It's as if a light has been turned on in his soul."

Bibliography

About AIT
Bérard Guy. Hearing Equals Behavior. Keats Publishing. Connecticut. USA. ISBN 0-87983-600-8. 1993. French edition: Audition Égale Comportment. Maisonneuve. France. ISBN 2-7160-0097-2. 1982.

About AIT (case studies)
Stehli Annabel. The Sound of a Miracle. Keats Publishing. Connecticut. USA. ISBN 1-900238-0658. 1991.
Stehli Annabel. Dancing in the Rain. Keats Publishing. Connecticut. USA. ISBN 0-9644838-0-7. 1995.

About Tomatis Method
Tomatis Alfred. The Conscious Ear. Station Hill Press. New York. USA. ISBN 0-88268-108-7. 1991. translated from French L'Oreille et la Vie. 1977, 1990.
Tomatis Alfred. The Ear and Language. Moulin. Ontario. Canada. ISBN 0-9697079-8-3. 1996. French editions 1963, 1978, 1991.

About SAMONAS
Steinbach Ingo. SAMONAS Sound Therapy. The Way to Health Through Sound. Techau Verlag. Germany. ISBN 3-931050-48-3. 1997. German editions 1990, 1994, 1997.

About Johansen Sound Therapy
Johansen Kjeld. Numerous research papers. Baltic Dyslexia Research Laboratory Bornholm. Denmark.

Comments:

  1. No Article Comments available

Post Your Comments:

About Pauline Allen

Pauline Allen AIT is a neuro-developmental practitioner and sound and light therapist working with adults and children with learning, behavioural and emotional difficulties. Over the years she has become aware that some of the chronic and acute medical conditions of those she sees bear relation to earlier CNS dysfunctions and that brain anomalies must not be overlooked. She is a Member of The International Association of Bérard Practitioners, is on the advisory board of the British Register of Complementary Practitioners for sound therapy and is a founder member of The Developmental Practitioners Association. She runs The Sound Learning Centre and may be contacted there at 12 The Rise, London. N13 5LE, Tel. 020 8882 1060, Fax. 020 8882 1040. pallen@thesoundlearningcentre.co.uk     www.thesoundlearningcentre.co.uk

  • June Sayer Homeopathy

    Training Academy Homeopathy Nutrition Reiki, Distant Learning. Diet, Health Screening, Detox, Stress

    www.homeopathinessex.co.uk

  • PROFESSOR Sheik IMAM

    Professor Sheik Imam is a famous professional leading African Healer who works with powerful spirits

    www.besthealer.co.uk

  • The Listening Centre

    London UK Centre for Tomatis Listening Therapy voice, language, depression, autism, dyslexia, stroke

    www.tuneyourears.com

  • CHAKRA BALANCING

    Aromatherapy creams & candles. Heal naturally No side effects. Holistic treatments, powerful courses

    www.organic-aromatherapy.co.uk

  • radical spirituality

    UK publisher of rejected knowledge in areas of esoteric thought and radical streams of spirituality.

    www.imagier.co.uk

top of the page